... there is this corruption of sensibility that sets in after the first few decades as a music nut, where you get more of a buzz from contemplating shit music than good music.
Not so much actually listening, but the idea of trying to understand it, work out what its appeal is, how on earth the creator thought it was a good idea to bring into the world.
Shit music can be better food for thought than good music, which somehow explains its existence more simply.
I say "not so much actually listening to shit" - but there is a stimulus from the sharp tang of something really rank and abject.... it's like an aural palate cleanser.... or a reset (or even 'rest; which is how mistyped it first) of sensibility
You get bored with your own likes and preferences.... the predictability of the reactions, how you're wired
It's interesting to wonder, what if I was a person who loved extreme metal and only wanted to listen to that.... and had consequently developed finely tuned discrimination for the different shades of aural offal.... what would it be like be like that?
It's a kind of decadence maybe.... like Des Esseintes in A Rebours, the lengths he has to go, to get off...
Well, of course, Eno said it first , said it punchiest:
"Really awful is more interesting to listen to than pretty good"
Which is the epigraph at Hardly Baked 2, whose output is largely if not wholly based on this approach (ShitBrit, the Bad Music Era, etc).
Puts me in mind of the Komar & Melamid project for "The Most Unwanted Song" (a counterpart to their "Most Wanted Song"), a construction of crowd-sourced elements of "bad" musical tropes (bagpipes, rapping opera singers, a children's choir, etc.) which of course turned out to be kind of not bad.
ReplyDeleteI know the feeling... Reminds me of Carl Wilson's book about Celine Dion, where he tries to think himself into the head-space of her fans, and listens to her music repeatedly to see if he can make himself like it.
ReplyDeleteBut on the other hand, is bad music really a good use of the finite number of listening hours allowed to us in our lifetimes? That's the question Paul Morley asks in his Classical music book. And I find it pretty compelling!
Genres of music often form part of an entire alien (to the likes of us) lifeworld, though. For example, fandom of the various genres of extreme Metal often comes with an enthusiasm for Dungeons & Dragons or Warhammer 40K. It goes beyond "taste" and into profound psychological differences that probably have some evolutionary component.
ReplyDeleteYes! The D&D => Metal conveyor belt has been a thing for 40 years, at least. I rode on it myself.
DeleteI have been thinking about music and lifeworlds (good word!) in connection to Bad Bunny, who I discovered via the Super Bowl. I had never knowingly heard a note of his music before then, but I thought he was terrific, and have been enjoying exploring his oeuvre. But his language, cultural background, daily life, etc are so remote from mine, I can only have a detached observer’s interest.
If you haven’t read the Carl Wilson book, I would highly recommend it. He is very interesting on a lot of these types of idea.
Craziest exploration of extreme musical self-absorption is this one, Ed:
Deletehttps://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/zer0-books/our-books/strangled
Ha! Looks great. Especially compelling as I used to be friends with a Stranglers superfan. You’ve got a sale!
DeleteCheers Ed!
Delete